Yes.
You need to fix the phone-and-recording layer before any CRM will help.
What's really going on
You're not shopping for a CRM. You're shopping for a cellular call recorder that saves to the cloud, plus a light place to hold contacts, notes and next-call dates. One small correction on the legal piece: Canada follows one-party consent under Criminal Code s.184(2)(a) — any participant in a conversation can record it without notifying the other party, and that rule applies in full in Alberta and covers landline, mobile, or internet telephony. So recording is legal, not required — you're doing it to protect yourself, not to comply. That reframes the whole stack: the CRM is the small part.
What to do instead
- A cellular call recorder — Rink or TapeaCall, roughly $10–15/mo (check pricing) — one-tap conference recording over your cell signal, cloud storage, auto-transcription. Canada is on the local-number list for Rink, so it works in Calgary without a data connection carrying the voice.
- Capsule CRM, free up to 250 contacts (check pricing) — one contact per client with a "last contacted" field and a task with a due date. That's your entire follow-up system.
- Fathom or Otter free tier — paste the transcript in, get action items back, drop them into Capsule as tasks. Do this same-day while the call is fresh.
First action, 30 minutes: install Rink, call your own voicemail once to test the recording lands in the cloud, then create the "Clients" list in Capsule and add your last five active files with a next-call date.
What you're being oversold
Follow Up Boss, BoldTrail, Lofty, HubSpot Sales Hub. These log meeting notes into their own workspace and route calls through their softphones — you'd be paying $80–200/mo to get the VoIP problem you already know Calgary can't support, plus IDX and lead-gen features you said you don't want. Doing nothing costs you the one client per year who disputes what you promised on a call — the recording is cheap insurance against a single commission-sized loss.
When to revisit this
When you're taking more than five client calls a day and Capsule's task list starts feeling like homework you skip.
The part worth getting right
Here's the fork. You can record manually — tap once per call in Rink — or automatically, by porting a business number to a service that PSTN-forwards to your cell and records the middle leg without you touching the phone. Manual is cheaper and works today; you'll miss the odd call you forget to tap. Automatic never misses, costs three to five times more, and needs you to hand out a new number. If you're the type who'll remember the tap on a stressful call, manual wins. If you know you won't, you need the forwarding service — and picking wrong means either lost recordings or a wasted $100/mo.